Important Info: 'THE FUNHOLE' is the book's birthname but the publishers wouldn't let Koja use it so she nicknamed it The Cipher but spiritually, it's THE FUNHOLE, which is, I feel, a far more apt moniker
in a nutshell: The most checked-out burnout your imagination can conjure is living a less-than-minimalist life of squalor, funded, in true 90s fashion, by a job at a video rental store. Everything about this kid is as frustratingly stagnant and stubbornly pathetic as his job, including his deeply inexplicable sorta-love for an absolutely feral (like, should be on psych meds at the least) gal with whom he has a classic super toxic early-20s situationship. But there is something determined to make this most unremarkable dude, interesting (by force if necessary): a strange black hole has appeared in the grotty storage room of his shitty apartment complex, and it is WEIRD, man. This hole is perhaps alive, perhaps a process, but it is definitely tied to our protagonist and it is definitely causing bizarre, twisted shit to happen to things that get too close. So of course, Miss Feral AF wants to do as many sicko experiments with the Funhole as possible, but our beleaguered Dude is being slowly, grossly, stripped of his sanity as the Funhole exerts ever more power over him, and everyone around him.
the vibes: laughing with the abyss, launching yourself into the abyss, being irrevocably changed by the abyss that you definitely let stare back into you; damaging situationships you just can't extract yourself from (but not the sapphic kind) (sadly); speciousness and malaise; male art hoes are the worst
main themes: the abyss (Nietzschean); the void (Lynchian); open wounds (physical and metaphorical); the mundane dangers of capital 'A' Apathy; the truest horrors are internal; transgression, crossing lines (but who draws those lines?); creation, and what happens "when those who can't create feed off those who do"
the writing: Koja is also a poet, and it shows in the prose (ha, perhaps I am also a poet!) Prose which, like our narrator, steadily spirals into disjointed, untethered insanity, but in an extremely readable way. The cadence of her writing made this an enjoyable one to read aloud to myself. As the decent into madness reaches its zenith, the sprawling sentences become manic, shifting focus so abruptly and frequently it gives you whiplash and then they go on and on and talking to you talking to themselves talking to no one and it feels like you are falling into the Funhole yourself. There's no way around it, this book is bleak, but there's a great sense of gallows humor peppered throughout the relentless misery so reading such misanthropic rage isn't a total slog. Koja's sentence architecture was so engaging that I could completely overlook that I really just wanted all of these characters to fucking jump down the Funhole already. The main character is wasted for most of the book, and the charmingly verbose repitition is truly evocative of a proselytizing drunk pal on a couch who is endearing but also after a while you just wish he'd let someone else talk. Actually, you're quickly gonna want all these characters to just shut the fuck up, but they are not the kind to do so, oh no siree.
I will confidently say this author has been to some bad afters because she perfectly captures the kickback in a crashpad atmosphere, down to the inane dialogue between persons so disparate that they could only be brought together in one space by the promise of (truly shitty) free beer.
"Pandora could not correct her original error, but I bet she didn't go around opening boxes anymore."
Having read some of Koja's short stories, through which I quickly fell in love with her vibrant use of language, I very much looked forward to this book, even as the book club pal who handed it to me warned "It is very fuckin' bleak." I expected a Sturm und Drang 'Reality Bites' of sorts, but the Funhole was far, far weirder than I'd anticipated. I can definitely dig its cult classic status, and see why it is credited for helping shift American horror lit into new territories. Published in 1991, you can imagine how radically different this would feel after a decade of slasher flicks and Stephen King best sellers.
Koja pretty quickly sets the expectations that there will be no one to root for, no cathartic ending, no answers. But there will be plenty of strangeness, dark humor, and tragedy. And then even more strangeness. Just like life. The cast of fascinatingly unlikeable characters grows wider as the weirdness spreads, forming theories and competing factions in attempts to understand and explain the Funhole's appearance, effects, and purpose. Yet there's no way to truly know, perhaps short of diving down the Funhole yourself, but there's a good chance you're not coming back from that. Again, like life. It just is, shittily enough. In the abject absurdism of The Cipher, we recognize too much of our own selves in these nasty characters, in their cowardice and harsh reactions, in the futility of their strive for change, for meaning, for solace. Koja's Funhole is itself an abyss that stares back at its reader, unsettles us, and leaves us changed.
I could not stop saying "Way harsh, Tai" to myself throughout reading this.